4The Unfocused Student
 

 


What Should a Good Thesis Do?

 

 

Once your student has determined a possible thesis statement, her thesis may need additional sharpening or clarifying. According to Margaret Oakes, a good thesis should:

1. Indicate the focus and scope of your argument. Examples:

Original thesis: Bram Stoker’s Dracula discusses the theme of science versus religion and shows the ways that the humans battle the undead.

Revised thesis: In Dracula, Bram Stoker shows the battle of science versus religion through the ways that the humans battle the undead.

Original thesis: In this essay, I will discuss the effects of pesticides on fish populations.

Revised thesis: The use of pesticides has not only decimated fish populations but has also endangered other creatures—including humans—who eat poisoned fish.

2. Indicate the organization of your paper. Example:

Original thesis: Many things have contributed to the uncertain position of NATO in the 1990s.

Revised thesis: Changes in the balance of European power, the decline of some previously important economies, and the growing importance of European ties to Middle Eastern, Asian and African countries have contributed to the uncertain position of NATO in the 1990s.

 3. State your position or argument in specific, concrete terms.

Original thesis: Joseph Conrad is an interesting but confusing writer.

Revised thesis: Heart of Darkness uses an elliptical and introverted sentence structure and a confusing use of pronouns to impart the monomania of Conrad's main character, Kurtz, and the difficulties that Marlow has in understanding him. (Oakes)

 

 

 
Home

The Writing Center: Past and Present The Student/Tutor Relationship The Clueless Student The Unfocused Student The Disorganized Student The Underdeveloped Student The Unrevised Student The Unpolished Student ESL Strategies Research Strategies Discipline-Specific Assignments Documentation Styles Writing Center Ethics Writing Center Publicity

 
© 1999, 2000, 2002 Virginia Bower (Mars Hill College), Charlene Kiser (Milligan College), Kim McMurtry (Montreat College), Ellen Millsaps (Carson-Newman College), Katherine Vande Brake (King College). All rights reserved. This manual was made possible by a Culpeper grant from the Appalachian College Association; click here for information. If you encounter difficulties with these web pages, please notify kmcmurtry@montreat.edu.